DNA stories: Evidence and Proof (Notes for the SAG Writing Discussion Group on 12 November 2020)

-


We all love sharing our DNA stories.  The challenge is what's that DNA we share with our DNA match proving?  This slide from Veronica Williams' presentation at our recent Irish Day is the challenge of genetic genealogy.  Evidence and proof are recurring themes in our AdvanceDNA Discussion Groups particularly when we're going public with our work!


Here's a slide I use when introducing DNA....you only need to read the heading as the next two slides tell the story of what's needed to meet the proof standard.  Why not join our DNA sessions and find out more?  Genetic genealogy is a new tool for the family historian and, as I now say, the biggest revolution for the family historian since the invention of paper!  Our understanding of using this tool in our family history is evolving very quickly.  


The next slide is a summary of the dot points above.  In essence, the more distant the likely relationship the more evidence is required to prove the relationship beyond reasonable doubt.  While we're not professional genealogists, we accept the need to embrace the Genealogy Standards of the Board for Certification of Genealogists (BCG).  You can read more HERE.



You can read the instruction that wikitree.com provides for DNA confirmations HERE.

This recently published article on How to Write and Publish a Proof Argument with DNA Evidence is both comprehensive and readable and essential for those of us who are looking to write about our DNA discoveries.

DNA Stories written by members of the SAG DNA Discussion Group

  • Veronica Williams' story of reuniting her Britton family is HERE.
  • Veronica's story on which Noll brother is her great-grandfather is HERE.
  • Vicki Hails' story of finding all the Brimble children is HERE.
  • Kathryn Barrett's story "The Gheas: Our Eurasian Family" is HERE.
  • My story written with Martyn Killion of reuniting Jane Feeney, our great-great grandmother, with her mother and siblings is HERE.
For members of the SAG-
  • Barbara McAlary's story of finding her great grandfather, Felix Chatel, is HERE.
  • My early Descent article about finding the family of my great-great grandmother, Mary Bonner, is HERE.
Louise Coakley's has hundreds more stories at genie1.com. au HERE.

Popular posts from this blog

MODULE 2: Grouping your AncestryDNA matches - The Leeds Method and my "twisted" Leeds Method

-
Image
These notes are for participants in the Society of Australian Genealogists' program, Analysing your AncestryDNA results . Others are welcome to use these notes for their personal research. Please contact me at  chrisw9953[at]gmail[dot]com for other uses.  I'll strive to update the notes as there are further developments or my understanding of the area grows. September 2024 - There have been recent updates at AncestryDNA including the optional subscription to ProTools. While my approach to grouping remains the same, I am now trialling slight changes to numbering and colouring to take advantage of these changes. For examples, groups are numbered as 1P and 1M rather than P1 and M1 as the number and colour of the group signifies the ancestral line. This post will be updated prior to the Summer 2025 program.  Introduction to the Leeds Method Click  HERE  to watch a twenty five minute video I've recorded on the Leeds Method and my "twisted" Leeds Method. Remembe...
Read more

MODULE 1: Working with AncestryDNA (Starting to solve your DNA dilemmas!)

-
Image
These notes are for participants in the Society of Australian Genealogists' program, Analysing your AncestryDNA results . Others are welcome to use these notes for their personal research. Please contact me at chrisw9953[at]gmail[dot]com for other uses. I'll strive to update the notes as there are further developments or my understanding of the area grows. AncestryDNA is autosomal testing - often called cousinship testing. You can read more about atDNA testing at Louise Coakley's excellent site - click  HERE.  Here's a pedigree chart provided by Louise. Any one of your ancestors could have passed atDNA down to you but, the more distant the ancestor, the less likely you'll have some of their atDNA. You don't need to know a lot of terminology but here are some you need to understand- It's essential that you get the relationship between the tester and the "cousin" the atDNA is shared with correct. So the "cousinship chart" is...
Read more

First look at AncestryDNA

-
Image
Update on Ancestry subscriptions- Most of your AncestryDNA matches will not have a subscription and will have very little information to work with.  If you don't have an Ancestry membership, you should consider "AncestryDNA Plus" which costs $39.99 each six months. You can read about the features included  HERE. Ancestry Pro Tools allows you to see how much DNA your matches share and their relationship to each other. The cost is variable but I pay $10US a month. You can read more HERE  and use the link to subscribe.  Below at are notes for those who attended the Society of Australian Genealogists' webinar First Look at AncestryDNA .  Others are welcome to use these notes for their personal research.  Please contact me at chrisw9953[at]gmail[dot]com for  other uses.  I'll strive to update the notes as there are further developments or my understanding of the area grows. "Setting the scene" You can read about the "4 types of DNA"  HERE. Ancestr...
Read more